NBAR and HTTP Data Conversations
I’m still working on the ONT test and doing labs, so I marked up a lab for me to work. I’m using the same setup as I did last time. The two routers are 3640s running 12.4(25b).
Part of the lab was to identify HTTP traffic coming into F0/0 and mark it as CS3. That’s pretty easy, right? Of course, the lab I made up was a little more complicated, but the point comes clear with a simpler example.
class-map match-all HTTP match protocol http ! policy-map PM-F0/0-IN class HTTP set dscp cs3 ! interface FastEthernet0/0 service-policy input PM-F0/0-IN
I fired off a small script on TestHost1 to repeatedly do NMap scans on TCP/80 of TestHost2 to generate some traffic.
root@bt:~#while ( true ) do nmap -sT -p 80 -v -n 172.16.2.101; done
I let that run for a while and checked out the service policy on F0/0; there were absolutely no matches on that class.
R1#sh policy-map int f0/0 input class HTTP FastEthernet0/0 Service-policy input: PM-F0/0-IN Class-map: HTTP (match-all) 0 packets, 0 bytes 5 minute offered rate 0 bps, drop rate 0 bps Match: protocol http QoS Set dscp cs3 Packets marked 0
I thought that was strange, so I kept the script running and captured the traffic coming out of S1/0. Looking at the packets in Wireshark showed that none of the HTTP packets were showing up as being marked as CS3; they’re all set to the default DSCP value.
On a whim, I enabled NBAR protocol discovery on F0/0 to see if that would shed any light on my mess. Guess what I found. That’s right; there were no HTTP matches to NBAR, either. That makes sense since the class-map I defined uses the NBAR protocol. Alright, so it seems that it’s NBAR that doesn’t see the packets as HTTP, but why?
Looking through the packet captures again, I noticed that there was no real data in the streams. I saw the 3-way TCP handshake (a.k.a., my signature wrestling move) and then a RST,ACK. I only told NMap to check if the port was open, so I changed the while loop a bit and enabled version detection with the “-sV” flag. This time when I can the script, NMap was actually getting the HTTP banner. It was much traffic, but it was an actual HTTP conversation, so I checked NBAR again. Success! The same for the class, too.
For craps and smiles, I created a class-map that matched SIP, added it to the same policy-map, and set NMap after TCP/5060 without version detection. Without having a real SIP conversation, the class counters incremented as long as I was sending packets. That would seem unexpected until you realize that NBAR has some advanced knowledge of HTTP; you can actually match on URLs, hostnames, and MIME-types. I guess that means it also know when a real HTTP conversation is taking place.
To finish out the testing, I added an ACL to the router that matched any-any-eq-80. I made the class-map into a match-any and added the ACL. Since the ACL just matches the destination port and doesn’t care what the content is, every packet sent matched the class as expected. I remember reading several places and seeing a couple videos that said that you can use NBAR matching and ACLs interchangeably. That may not really be true when it comes to HTTP.
Cisco learning credits questions my way.
- Generating Network Diagrams from Netbox with Pynetbox - August 23, 2023
- Out-of-band Management – Useful Beyond Catastrophe - July 13, 2023
- Overlay Management - July 12, 2023